Pour-Over Will: Does It Avoid Probate?

The enforceability of restrictive covenants and non-compete agreements depends on various factors, including how and when the employee/contractor initially signed the document. A company or employer may find it easier to enforce these agreements if they work with business law attorneys in Pittsburgh during the initial drafting and signing processes. If a company can steer clear of common mistakes from the very beginning, it can protect its competitiveness and avoid issues caused by former employees/contractors. Pennsylvania Only Enforces Non-Compete Agreements That Meet Five Requirements While Pennsylvania does not have a clear statute governing non-compete agreements, past cases have established a three-part test for their enforceability. First, a non-compete agreement must clearly define a timeframe in order to be enforceable. In other words, it must have an expiry date. You cannot stop an employee or contractor from competing indefinitely. Case law also suggests that non-compete agreements with the strongest enforceability are only valid for a few years (and not decades). A Pennsylvania court is also likely to reject a non-compete agreement with an ill-defined scope. In other words, the contract must describe exactly what the employee or contractor is prohibited from doing. The scope must also be reasonable, meaning you can only prevent employees from joining clear competitors. If a company is only distantly related to your industry or field, a non-compete probably can’t prevent your former employee from joining that organization. Scope also encompasses the type of company information that the employee uses to compete in the future. You cannot stop a former employee from using their own inherent skills and knowledge to set up a competing business. The only way you can legitimately curb competition from a former employee is by limiting the way they use your company’s “confidential information.” You might be surprised to learn that your former employees have every right to use company information that you consider to be confidential. As long as that information is publicly available, your employees can use it freely. This includes price lists, your suppliers' contact information, and general business practices well-known in your industry. One example of “confidential information” in this context is a list of your customers, complete with their email addresses and telephone numbers. Although this information might be publicly available, a normal person would not be able to recreate the finished list without spending years building a business (as you have). Intellectual property is another example of protected, confidential business information. If you have gone through the trouble of obtaining a patent or a copyright, your employee has no right to steal this information and use it to set up a competing business. The same logic applies to “trade secrets,” which may include confidential formulas or recipes. That said, it is important to remember that these violations are governed by intellectual property law, and not necessarily non-compete agreements. Non-compete agreements in Pennsylvania must also clearly define their geographical “reach.” You can only prevent an employee from competing with you in your geographical area, such as the City of Pittsburgh or Allegheny County. Even if your employee signs a non-compete agreement, they could theoretically travel to another state or country before starting a competing business. Finally, companies in Pennsylvania generally need to offer employees or contractors something in return for signing non-compete agreements. If the penalties for violating the agreement represent the “stick,” then the reward represents the “carrot.” In business law, this reward is called “consideration.” A common type of consideration is a job offer. With the job offer on the table, there is a clear reward for signing the non-compete agreement. On the other hand, the potential employee could always walk away from the job offer without excessive penalties. Another type of consideration is career advancement. This might be a raise or a promotion. An employee may decide to sign a non-compete agreement in order to access these career benefits. If they reject the offer, they would presumably keep their current position in the company without any other consequences. Pennsylvania courts may deem unenforceable a non-compete agreement that lacks these promised rewards. In the eyes of the court, an employee faces a difficult situation if they could lose their job by not signing a non-compete agreement. As with all contracts, duress or undue influence can make non-compete agreements unenforceable. Penalties Help Enforce Valid Non-Compete Agreements Assuming a non-compete agreement is valid, what exactly stops an employee from violating it? Without effective penalties, a non-compete agreement is useless. You can enforce your non-compete agreements with “injunctions.” These are court orders that require your former employee or contractor to immediately stop working for the competing business. If they have set up their own business, a court order could force them to shut down operations. Penalties may also include damages. The court can order the competing employee or contractor to pay compensation for your losses. For example, an employee might have stolen all of your customers by offering the same services for a lower price. In this situation, you could recover all of the profit you would have earned if those customers had remained loyal. Negotiation Is Often the First Step of Enforcement While taking your former employee or contractor to court can lead to positive results, most parties attempt to resolve their disputes through negotiation first. Indeed, mandatory “arbitration clauses” are often built into non-compete agreements. A business law attorney can represent your best interests during these negotiations, ensuring positive outcomes without an expensive, time-consuming trial. Can a Business Law Attorney in Pittsburgh Help Me? A b usiness law attorney in Pittsburgh may be able to help if you are serious about making your restrictive covenants and non-compete agreements as enforceable as possible. Legal assistance with drafting and negotiating these agreements from the outset may improve their enforceability if a dispute arises later. That said, lawyers can also help resolve disputes over restrictive covenants signed long in the past. To explore this topic further, consider contacting Cozza Law Group, PLLC at (412) 790-2789. You can also find us online .